Search your own trade and your own town on your phone right now. Not your business name. The trade and the town, the way a customer would. Three businesses show up on the map above everything else. If you are not one of them, this article is about how to become one. If you are, it is about staying there.

How Google picks the three

Google says it plainly in its own help pages. Local results are ranked on three things: relevance, distance and prominence.1 Relevance is how well your profile matches what was typed. Distance is how far you are from the searcher, or from the place they named. Prominence is how well known you are, and for a contractor that is mostly reviews: how many, how recent, how good.

Most contractors spend all their worry on the third one and never fix the first two. That is backwards. Reviews are the tiebreaker. If Google does not think you are relevant to the search or close to the searcher, the reviews never get a chance to break the tie.

Distance for a business that drives to the customer

If you work at the customer's house, Google calls you a service-area business. You do not show a storefront address; you tell Google which areas you serve, and it lets you list them by city, county or ZIP code.2 This is where the first mistake happens. People either leave it blank, list only their home ZIP, or draw a circle over the entire state to look bigger.

Blank means Google guesses, badly. One ZIP means you are invisible two towns over. The whole state means you look equally irrelevant everywhere, because a pressure washer who claims Jacksonville and Key West does not look like a real business in Sarasota. Google's own guidelines say to list the areas you actually serve, and the practical advice is the same: be honest and specific.3

A Brandon electrician who lists all of Hillsborough looks less relevant in Brandon than one who lists Brandon, Valrico and Riverview.

So list the towns you drive to. If you are in Bradenton and you take jobs in Palmetto, Ellenton and Parrish, list them. If you will not go to Tampa, do not list Tampa. The service area is a promise about where you show up, and Google rewards the ones it can believe.

Relevance is mostly categories and pages

Your primary category is the single most important field on the profile. "Pressure washing service" and "Cleaning service" are different searches. "Plumber" and "Water heater installation service" are different searches. Pick the primary category that matches the job that pays your bills, then add secondary categories for the rest. Fill in the services list underneath with the specific jobs, in the words a homeowner uses, not the words on your invoice.

Then there is the website, which most people treat as a business card. Google reads it. If your site is one page that says "serving the Gulf Coast," Google has nothing to match against a search for "lanai rescreen Venice." If your site has a page about lanai rescreening and a page about Venice, and those pages link to each other, now there is something to match. That is the entire reason the sites I build have one page per service and one page per area instead of one long scroll.

Prominence, without gaming anything

Reviews are prominence. The rules matter here because Google removes reviews it thinks are bought, faked or coerced, and can suspend profiles that push it.4 You cannot pay for reviews, offer discounts for them, or review-gate by only asking happy customers in a way that blocks the unhappy ones from posting.

What you can do is ask everyone, consistently, right after the job, and make it easy. A text with the direct review link the same day the work is done gets far more responses than a card left on the counter. Follow up once or twice if they forget. Respond to every review, good and bad, in your own words. A steady trickle of real reviews every month beats a burst of thirty in one week that looks exactly like what it is.

The reason I automate this for contractors is not that it is complicated. It is that nobody remembers to do it after the fourth job of the day. The system texts the customer, follows up, and routes low ratings to you first so you can fix the problem. It runs whether you remember or not. Here is the long version of how that works.

The checklist, in the order that matters

Why the neighborhood approach beats the big guys

In a market like Tampa or St. Petersburg, the franchises and the investor-owned companies own the paid results. They can outspend anyone on ads. What they cannot do is look like the plumber from Seminole Heights to someone in Seminole Heights. The map results reward the business that is close, relevant and well reviewed in that specific place, and a well set up independent wins that fight in its own neighborhoods. That is the whole strategy behind the city pages on this site, and it is the same one I build into every contractor's profile and website. $297 a month, no contract, built before you pay.

Want this built for you?

I build the website by hand, free. You don't pay a dollar until it's live and you like it — then it's $297/mo, no contract, cancel anytime. Or just get the next post in your inbox.

Book a Call Subscribe for More
  1. 1. Google Business Profile Help, How to improve your local ranking on Google: relevance, distance and prominence. https://support.google.com/business/answer/7091
  2. 2. Google Business Profile Help, Service-area businesses on Google: how to set and edit service areas. https://support.google.com/business/answer/9157481
  3. 3. Google Business Profile Help, Guidelines for representing your business on Google. https://support.google.com/business/answer/3038177
  4. 4. Google Maps user contributed content policy: what is and is not allowed in reviews. https://support.google.com/contributionpolicy/answer/7400114